nadoosh 🍓

Ziegfeld Girl

why were sandra and sheila down bad for loser men who were jealous of their success?

josie

Ziegfeld Girl

MGM’s glitzy melodrama Ziegfeld Girl is a dazzling, frustrating, and occasionally heartbreaking ride through the lives of three young women caught up in the glimmering promise and grim realities of show business. With stunning costumes, elaborate musical numbers, and a star-studded cast, it’s easy to get swept away in the spectacle. But beneath the sequins lies a story of ambition, heartbreak, and the maddening limitations society placed on women, especially when it comes to the men in their lives. Let’s just get this out of the way: the men are AWFUL. Nearly every male character in this film manages to be controlling, selfish, or just plain disappointing. Whether it’s the overbearing father figure, the jealous husband, or the insecure boyfriend threatened by success, it’s like a parade of red flags in fedoras. These men are constantly dragging the women down, trying to tame them or clip their wings, all while hiding behind performative concern or fragile egos. It’s maddening and depressingly realistic. That said, James Stewart, playing truck driver-turned-fiancee Gil, is the film’s lone male saving grace. He’s as charming and earnest as ever, bringing warmth and humanity to a role that could’ve easily fallen flat. Even when Gil is making questionable choices, Stewart’s charisma pulls you in. That scene where he’s talking to Sheila about the ducks? Absolute cinema. Now let’s talk about Sandra, who gives up her rising career to support her man’s ego and dreams. And while it’s played like a noble sacrifice, it is INFURIATING. Sandra’s journey could have been one of balance and mutual growth, but instead it turns into a cautionary tale about how women are expected to shrink themselves to let men shine. She deserved better. Her talent, grace, and strength are thrown away for a man who couldn’t handle her success. Watching her choose domesticity over her own career isn’t heartwarming, it’s tragic! And then there’s Sheila, played with scene-stealing brilliance by Lana Turner. Sheila’s descent from glamour to despair is the film’s emotional core, and Turner gives it everything she’s got. Her performance is electrifying; vivacious and vulnerable, sharp and sympathetic. Sheila does make some poor choices, and yes, she kind of brings it on herself with her pride and pursuit of the high life. But that doesn’t make her downfall any less sad. Watching her self-destruct, trading genuine connection for champagne and chandeliers, is devastating. Poor Sheila, she burns so bright before crashing down in that unforgettable finale. Turner’s performance is PHENOMENAL, a career highlight, really. She outshines even the lavish production numbers, making Sheila’s story the one you remember long after the last note fades. For all its visual splendor and standout performances, Ziegfeld Girl is held back by its regressive gender politics and a sometimes uneven narrative. The musical sequences, while gorgeous, slow the pace. And the film ultimately reinforces a frustrating message: women can either have love or success, but never both. I understand this was commonplace for the time but that doesn’t mean I have to like it. Still, there’s no denying its impact or the talent of its leading ladies. Ziegfeld Girl is totally worth watching, if only to marvel at Turner’s tragic brilliance, Stewart’s charm, and the infuriating reminder of how little space women were once allowed to take up, even under the spotlight.

The Raven.

Ziegfeld Girl

i miss you, my ziegfeld girl

ؘ

Ziegfeld Girl

I didn't like this, felt empty 80% of the time. But i have a thing for actresses so a big kiss to Hedy Lamarr, Judy Garland and Lana Turner.